You are currently viewing A Comprehensive Guide to the Different Courts in South Africa

A Comprehensive Guide to the Different Courts in South Africa

The judicial system of any country is a vital component of its governance, ensuring the fair and just application of laws. South Africa is a country with a very rich history and diverse population, and the courts system plays a crucial role in upholding justice and maintaining the rule of law.

Whether you are a legal professional or looking to pursue legal action, having a clear understanding of the types of courts available to you as well as their respective jurisdiction is crucial.

In this article, we aim to shed some light on the various courts in South Africa, their jurisdictions, and their significance in the legal landscape. We will begin with the highest court in the land to the smallest.

Constitutional Court

At the pinnacle of South Africa’s judicial hierarchy lies the Constitutional Court. Established in 1994, this court is responsible for safeguarding the Constitution and ensuring its supremacy.

 The ‘Concourt’, as it is mostly referred to, is the highest court in South Africa when it comes to constitutional matters. Its jurisdiction includes hearing appeals from the Supreme Court of Appeal, Specialist Courts, the High Court or certain matters referred to it by the President.

The main role of the Constitutional Court is to interpret the South African Constitution and ensure that all other courts and government institutions adhere to it. The jurisdiction of the Constitutional Court includes hearing appeals from the Supreme Court of Appeal and certain matters referred to it by the President. The Court also has the power to declare any law or conduct inconsistent with the Constitution as invalid.

The Constitutional Court is the only court that can decide whether Parliament or the President has failed to fulfil a constitutional duty or obligation. When the High Court has declared any decision made by the Government or an Act of Parliament unconstitutional and invalid, the Constitutional Court has to confirm this declaration before it can have legal effect.

The Constitutional Court has the final say in constitutional matters and its decisions are binding on all other courts. This means that no other court can overturn a decision or judgment made by the Constitutional Court.

Supreme Court of Appeal

The Supreme Court of Appeal is the second highest court in South Africa, however, it serves as the highest court for non-constitutional matters. Its jurisdiction primarily includes hearing and reviewing judgments and orders from lower courts, and ensuring consistency and correctness in legal interpretations.

The Supreme Court of Appeal is the final court of appeal in most cases, except in those cases that involve the interpretation of the Constitution, or if it is an issue of general public importance.

The Supreme Court of Appeal has previously played a very important role in shaping South African law. Some of its most notable cases include the case of Olympic athlete Oscar Pistorius, and the “spy tapes” case, involving the decision to drop corruption charges against former President Jacob Zuma.

Anyone who wants to appeal a decision or judgment made by a lower court needs to understand the role and jurisdiction of the Supreme Court of Appeal.

High Court

South Africa has various High Courts that are spread across all of its provinces, each with jurisdiction over a specific geographic area. Each province has a main High Court building that is usually situated in the provincial capital. However, certain provinces like the Gauteng, KwaZulu-Natal, Eastern Cape, and Mpumalanga have more than one High Court building which is called the local seat of the provincial division.

The High Court is a court that has general jurisdiction, this means that it deals with a wide range of civil and criminal matters. It hears civil matters wherein the claim amount is above R400 000, divorces, as well as serious criminal matters such as treason, murder, and rape. It also hears disputes between individuals or companies and the government.

The High Court also deals with the Constitution to some extent, in that, it has jurisdiction to interpret legislation which was passed by Parliament and review decisions which were taken by the Government and declare them unconstitutional and invalid.

The High Court deals with more complex matters and it is also the place where the most important legal precedents are established, therefore it is important for anyone who wishes to pursue legal action to understand its role and jurisdiction.

Magistrate’s Court

The Magistrate’s Court serves as the entry point for most legal matters in South Africa.

Magistrates’ courts are divided into district and regional courts. The District Courts hear all civil matters with a claim amount below R200,000 as well as less serious criminal cases which include offences other than rape, murder or treason. The Regional Courts hear civil cases with a claim amount below R400,000, and they may also hear more serious criminal matters which include serious assault, rape or murder.

The Magistrates Court also sits as the Equality Court to hear cases that involve discrimination or harassment. It may also sit as the Children’s Court, to hear cases that involve children; the Family Court, to hear cases that involve domestic violence, child custody, maintenance and parental rights, and uncomplicated divorces.

The Magistrate’s Court plays a crucial role in ensuring accessibility to justice for a broad spectrum of society, offering a faster and more informal legal process.

Small Claims Court

Small claims courts hear civil cases involving a claim amount below R20 000. Claims are usually brought by individuals against other individuals rather than companies or the government.

The Small Claims Court may not hear cases that involve divorces, claims against the State, evictions, or disputes involving a will. Judgments or decisions of the Small Claims Court may be taken on appeal or procedural review in the High Court.

Specialist Courts

There are various specialist courts that deal with matters in specific areas of law. These courts have a status which is similar to the High Court and are presided over by judges.

Specialist Courts include Tax Courts, the Labour Court, the Land Claims Court and the Electoral Court.

Decisions of all of these courts, except for the Labour Court, may be taken on appeal or procedural review in the Supreme Court of Appeal. In the Labour Court appeals or procedural reviews will go to the Labour Appeal Court which is also a specialist court that has a status similar to that of the Supreme Court of Appeal.

Tribunals

Various tribunals were established by legislation to hear legal disputes. These tribunals include the Water Tribunal which hears all disputes that involve water use and licensing; the Rental Housing Tribunal which involves disputes between housing tenants and landlords; the National Consumer Tribunal which involves consumer credit disputes in terms of the National Credit Act and Consumer Protection Act; the Companies Tribunal hears certain disputes arising from the Companies Act.

Decisions which are made by these tribunals, except for the Competition Tribunal, can only be taken on procedural review, and not appeal, in the High Court. In the Competition Tribunal, appeals or procedural reviews will go to the Competition Appeal Court, which is a specialist court that has a status similar to the Supreme Court of Appeal.

Traditional Courts

Traditional Courts operate in South African rural areas and are based on customary law. These courts have their own set of rules and procedures that are different from the mainstream legal systems in place, they are presided over by traditional leaders.

It is important to mention that jurisdiction of these courts is limited to disputes that arise within the community and are based on customary law. Traditional Courts were primarily designed to respect and uphold customary law and traditions. Its purpose is to provide access to justice for individuals who do not necessarily have access to mainstream courts.

Contact Us

The diverse range of courts in South Africa reflects the complexity of its legal system and our commitment to justice and equality. From the Constitutional Court upholding the principles of the Constitution to Magistrate’s Courts providing accessible justice, each court serves its unique purpose.

As South Africa continues to evolve, its courts will play a vital role in shaping the nation’s future while upholding the values of fairness, equality, and the rule of law.

It is important to understand the different types of courts as well as their respective roles and jurisdictions in order to choose the right court for your case. This will ensure that your case is heard by the appropriate court and that you have the best chance of obtaining a fair and just outcome.

Please note that the information provided in this blog post is general in nature and should not be construed as legal advice. For specific legal guidance, we encourage you to reach out to our team of experienced attorneys.

Leave a Reply